The game was abandoned so practically no one cares anymore, however, among the infinite mistakes of this aberration disguised as Visual Novel, I wanted to say that i think Raphael is not that bad.
This game is bad, its writing is terrible and it massacres all the characters without mercy, but, Raphael is... Cool? I mean, when MC was sent to hell... What the hell could she do? The father ordered it, the mother agreed, Aazel took MC to hell, and Raphael didn't participate in any of it, on the contrary, unlike Azael who claimed not to be afraid of father (But chose to stay with him for who knows how long), Raphael immediately chose to leave with her mother (Because the mother of the year turned her back and was leaving alone) and spent the next years trying to rescue MC, even going as far to be ready for a suicidal fight against a guardian (At this point i don't remember what that thing was anymore, but I think everyone knows the scene i'm referring to), to try to rescue him, and just stopped trying when MC returned to earth. Unlike her mother, she doesn't throw herself at him like a whore in heat all the time ignoring that the MC is a traumatized guy, and she doesn't make jokes and mockery about how "dense" the MC is about the world like Azael, Rapahel seems to be the only one really concerned there..
The writing is pathetic, and pathetic writing destroys all the characters, even Azael and mother could be much more likable if the writer had any idea what he was doing.
But, even among all the disaster, I like Raphael, I think she's the only one, even though she's also being massacred by the terrible writing, salvageable at this final point, since the game was abandoned.
If this game one day come back, the author needs to call a writer, because not everything in this VN is bad, the concept is good just terribly executed in all areas, something good could come out of it, but, well...
someone who could produce a VN from the scratch would be requiring "white bear’s permission. 
